A few weeks ago, I signed into a long forgotten, half-way abandoned Yahoo account. There was a whole bunch of spam and I was about to empty the contents of the Inbox when I noticed what appeared to be a long e-mail thread. The names were exclusively Desi and appeared to be real. After reading a few messages, I realized that my id had been inadvertently included in the class of ’92 mailing list of a well known engineering school in India.
Reading some more, I noticed the absence of any females in the group – I should have clued into that sooner given the frequency of risque humor and the terms of endearment that people employed to address each other. The only time the group curbed its enthusiastic use of expletives was when someone announced the birth of a child accompanied by pictures of the infant.
The politics, psychology, physics and metaphysics of the Zidane head-butt was discussed for several weeks. Of course, I did not see the point given India does not make it even to the qualifying rounds of the World Cup. Most other conversations were idle ramblings or read like announcements on a bulletin board (A changed jobs, B moved cities, C is organizing the Alumni meet at Phoenix this year, D is going to be in Norway for six months anyone else out there ? Anyone know the whereabouts of E who has been unaccounted for since 1997 etc)
A couple of things about this group and the their mailing list got me thinking. The frequency of the mailings was nothing short of alarming. Averaging between 20 to 30 mails a day, they had inundated my mailbox in a little over a month. I am assuming in addition to this there were private message threads being exchanged on a one to one basis. Though they had very little of consequence to talk about as a group, they seemed to care a lot about banding close together as they must have doubtless done 14 years ago.
That is a lot of e-mail traffic for anyone who has a job to keep, children to rear and bills to pay. These are men approaching 40, doing well professionally (by most standards), husbands, father of children, responsible for making mortgage payments among other things. Work and higher education had dispersed them geographically and I would think given them opportunities to meet new people and interface with new cultures.
Being more like the E who has been “unaccounted for since 1997”, I find it hard to imagine what a group of 40 odd that first came together as adolescents corralled for four years in the same college campus could have in common in their late 30s. I can understand an Alum organization serving as a professional or even personal network but this group had way more passion than it takes to sustain a mere "network".
I had to wonder if their lives were so empty that they needed a relic from the past to imbue it with a sense of purpose and fullness. Or perhaps no achievement in their lives compared to being accepted by a top tier engineering school in India – it probably short circuited brain receptors that enable normal people to savor their post-collegiate existence.
If not anything a mistaken email identity gave me opportunity to see the dynamic of desi-male bonding from the vantage point of a fly on the wall. I left feeling that the state of jejune juvenilia is permanent with the desi-male. They never quite break free from the familiar cocoon of the college fraternity. Their identity at middle age is still defined by nicknames bestowed upon them as 18 year olds by other 18 year olds and 20 year old jokes regurgitated ad nauseum. I would have expected a discourse more sophisticated, eclectic and mature from a group of well educated men of their age and circumstances in life.
It’s not often that a mailbox clean-up exercise puts my dating disasters in such clear perspective. Now, this E sounds like a man after my own heart – small wonder then that he is MIA since 1997.
Comments
pradz
Well, well, well!
Now I am on to both of you! It appears that both you and IW are real nautanki-baaz characters, who only crib about bachelorhood to advertise that you are single.
In reality, you both seem to be quite uninterested in getting rid of your bachelor status. And here I was, naively running from pillar to post, to help out you two!
Just wait till the next time IW cribs about his bachelorhood…
(Which should be in the next comment that he posts, since he does not miss out on any opportunity to crib at all)
Bingo!
(Ah, finally! Being on DSS is paying off for pradzie!)
Well, yeah, pradzie is a great guy (albeit a bit shy), and I am quite sure he can evoke his mallu genes if the occasion demands.
Now, how do we go about this?
Pradzie? You wanna send in your biodata first, as a gentleman aughta do? Do take a shot - this might be a match made in heaven, from HC’s description of the girl.
(Do be sure it includes a pic of you in the traditional lungi, as being a hardcore mallu is going to stand you in good stead here)
Thanks all !
Atra, IW and Pradz - appreciate all your efforts. I have a charming, bright and single friend that is looking. IW seems like a great match for her. But back in the college years her crush used to be Mallu and very-Mallu at that if you get my drift. So, maybe Pradz is the man for her. If there is enough interest, I’d be glad to make the introductions and may the best man win. As for me, would you guys rather not have me venture into the world of borderline demented, highly delusional divorced desi males and live to write about my adventures ?
HC - The Matchmaker, Thank
HC - The Matchmaker,
Thank you warmly for the keen interest taken in us bachelors. But i’m not as ‘mal’ as i’d wish to be, more of a ‘mal’function. And i’m not really looking right now. How can i pass up a chance to crib about not finding a girl when i’m a lil older? I’m going to wait… and in no hurry to tie a noose err knot. IW, in all respects is the respectful kinda dude, he should give it a shot. I can’t lie as well about him as well as he’s lied about me, but can say this much, he’s a cool whackier-than-thou dude.
Atra - _________
Can’t find a title that fits you best. And i don’t know what to say? Liek they say “You got my goat, dawg!”
phokat ka guru
Arrey wah! Bina dakshina diye you are running away?? Badaa chalu chela hai!
If you were a worthwhile chela, you’d not shirk from offering me even the thumb with which you click your mouse!
But this is kalyug, where makkhichoos chelas abound! I know, you are only hell-bent on saving tuition fees by choosing yourself as a guru.
Theek hai.
To itch his own, is what I say, to your decision.
May the buddha be with you, no matter how makkhichoos you are!
(And don’t you dare to come back to ask for your school-leaving certificate!)
IW ki baraat
Pradz,
I shall finally be undiplomatic and reveal to you why I push for IW’s baraat and not so much at yours.
1. As the adage goes - jo baccha rota hai, usiko pehle doodh milta hai. And boy, does IW cry about his singularity! I suspect that he will eventually shame us all into hunting for a suitable girl for him, and being farsighted, I am already working on it.
2. IW is unfortunately a ghaati, unlike you who are a mallu, by God’s grace. As the world knows (and as one of my mallu classmates used to proudly proclaim) - mallus are just full of sex and sex appeal. The world also knows that in terms of sex appeal, us ghaati guys lack as much on it as ghaati girls shine with it. Hence, in terms of needing a push, IW needs it much more than you do.
3. I did not think you would accept help, because as my other mallu friend used to say - “sher hamesha shikar khud key dam pe karta hai!”. As of now, IW is doing his internship in becoming that sher in the land of shers, singa-pore. When he graduates from there, he should be ready to go prowling on his own.
Besides, I had absolutely no idea that ananth, kculon and nemo were single and eligible. So, if you find it appropriate, I shall advocate your cause to the eligible girls here (I don’t know if that will further your cause or only cause your cause to retrogress, instead, as you guys are fully aware that about 73.58% of girls here have gotten into a comment-tiff with me sometime or the other)
I think the 2nd point and
I think the 2nd point and your mallu friend are a little over-the-top. Mallus are not always about sex alone. I mean C’mon, sure we’ve got Shakeela and the biggest porn industry in the country, but that doesn’t mean mallus are always in a romp mode. But yes, i think i would liek to see IW graduating and hopefully we all will make it to the graduation ceremony (his wedding).
And yes we know of your tiffs with the women. Its pretty nice, I actually like it. Think you start maintainin a RDBMS software tokeep track of who, where, when and why they picked a argument with you. God help them, ladies.
pradz
Yeah, perhaps my mallu friend was a bit over the top.
But then whats the spice in a mallu if he’s not a bit over the top, hm?
And dude, its not so much about being in romp mode as its about exuding sex appeal, man!
About IW, my best wishes are with him, but the way he insists on running himself down, his only hope is with a woman who has a real good sense of humor, and thats a very very rare breed to find. (Well, yeah, okay, thats a sexist statement - so shoot me).
Nominations for the post of IW's Guru
I would like to hereby nominate HC as the new and upgraded Guru of IW. (Its about time, after he irrevocably messed up the brains of his two previous gurus)
My nomination is based on the fact that IW sorely needs to learn some diplomacy (C’mon, he actually suggests that he is promoting pradzie because “those who need help should be helped”!).
And, I can think of none better than HC to teach our diplomatically challenged IW a thing or two, and to create at least an illusion of some order in that organ that he refers to as his “messed-up brain”.
As for introducing someone to the eligible HC, we can go with the equally eligible pradzie, if IW is unwilling (for whatever sick reasons he may have).
Pink Slip for Guru Atraa..
>> “those who need help should be helped”!
There you go again my Ex-Gury No.2 (EGN2), twisting my words. When i said Pradz needs help, I didn’t mean he needed help like thaakur Baldev Singh of Sholay (for lifting his Shawl back, after it had fallen down on ground). Pradzz is very much able bodied & talented. The only thing he lacked was a good PR. (Unlike me) he is too shy to blow his own trumpet. Buss thats all. Baaki ladkaaa heera hein heera
Anyways I stand vindicated after Pradz comment about how the Southern fraternity was feeling overwhelmed & neglected by 3 overtly agressive ghaatis. The playing field is even now, thanx to my selfless gesture. Atraa, herez your Pink slip & herez your pro-rated full & final Guru Dakshinaa. Go find Urself a new chelaa. Mein toh chalaa. And just for records, I am gonnaa be my own Guru from now own. Am gonna get in touch with the Buddha within me. PEACE.
IW - ek saccha dost!
Dude, you are hopeless!
Here I am, trying to introduce you to a girl that potentially has a brilliant future in high-end diplomacy, and here you are, running yourself down even in your introduction!
Why don’t you talk about the rippling muscles, about your non-possessive approach to life, about all the money you have tucked away (by saving toothpaste), about your contribution to environmental consciousness (by not owning any fossil fuel guzzling vehicle), and your holding out for THE girl to come along??
Or is it that I am mistaken and actually there is an agenda behind your stepping back in modesty, hm?
Oh, c’mon dude, don’t be so damn mature!
IW - the proverbial bali ka bakraa
>> and actually there is an agenda behind your stepping back in modesty, hm?
Aaaahh !!! the price one pays to be honest these days !! Honesty isn’t a virtue anymore, is it ? Gandhiji had written somewhere.. “Help those : who can’t help themselves” (Well, even if he hasn’t, I know if he was alive he would have certainly approved to what I am saying here)
Look at Pradz & look at me. Between him & me, who do u think needs “Help” ?? I am (already) singlemindedly pursuing Laalu. I don’t need any diversion when I am sooo close to winning Laalu (& her Dogs) heart(s). So i thought of being little philanthropic this time & let Pradz take centre stage for a change. Besides, mein hee bali kaa bakraa kyu banu har time
p.s. : Asuph asks me not act juvenile. Atraa asks me not be so mature. Between my Guru & ex. Guru I got to decide now, whom should I listen to most ??!! C’mon guys don’t mess with my already messed up brain.
choose...
… a new guru IW. Much simpler. Choose someone who already has the infrastructure in place to make your pursuit a lot easier, a la Osha
instead of boiling your brains over long distance cyberadvice 
So much for my IQ…
I still haven’t figured out what I wrote in that comment for it to be considered “potential spam”
The Stereotype
IMO, college kids happily passing ribald remarks among themselves are no less mature than, say, a head of state who convinces his country that their well-being lies in dropping bombs on a nation that has never attacked them.
Yet, why does society not equate maturity with the former, but does it most willingly in the latter?
This is because our ability to sense maturity (whether in ourselves or others) has become absurdly limited to the mere identification of a certain choice of words, with a specific type of behaviour and body language, with a certain dress code and diction. (And perhaps with some other personal likes thrown in for good measure).
And the moment we see the absence of the qualities that make up the stereotype of the mature male, we jump up to say, ah, THATS not mature!
IMO, this does not have as much to do with DMB girls or immature guys, as much as it has to do with one’s mind being influenced by the social stereotype of the inane male, a stereotype that shines with such power and glare, that it obscures the other things that may be visible. Clearly, in this example, only the stereotype has been seen, and nothing else.
And to be sure, a stereotype creates or evokes another.
As this one immediately brings to mind the stereotype of the DMB girl - to be sure, the stereotype of the DMB girl is shining brightly here, as well. One could almost make a statement, that from the stereotype of the DMB female, the stereotype of the inane male is perpetuated and maintained. And vice versa.
Perhaps, maturity lies in living a life beyond stereotypes.
Stereotypes are images of the mind, and we humans seem to be limited to idol worship (or condemnation), never actually seeing the one that the idol is associated with.
I think, without exception, we are all reasonably pathetic, in the end.
I think I’ll give my friend a holler, and we both will go and faff around somewhere, and talk about hindi movies and about that new actress with that most wholesome and shiny derriere.
HC
An excellent example of the fine art of massaging one’s opinions back into a PC mold after having discovered that what one said (or should one use the perception altering word “vented”?) was not so PC.
You would make a good diplomat - we need people like you in the foreign relations department
In this world there is always a place for talent.
BTW, I would like to introduce you to my friend IW. He’s a nice guy, mostly, you know. Fun loving, intelligent (if you could only overlook some of his prima facie inanities), and with a philosophical aversion to brushing more than once a day.
Introducing.. Pradz - da Man..
Thanx Atraa for the heads up. HC, nice meeting you. Allow me to introduce myself properly.
Me, India Whining :
- am in my early 30s
- am not balding (but I do have greying problem)
- don’t have a paunch (or so I would like to believe)
- don’t own a car, bike or even a bicycle
- I don’t have any Credit Card (could never fulfill their eligibility criteria)
- I own (through inheritance) a very modest 1 Rm-Kitchen apartment in suburban Mumbai (which I share with my mom)
- I don’t have a GF or Ex.Wife (Read above, to understand the reasons behind my extended bachelorhood)
**sigh** Its alright, You don’t need to be subtle in turning me down as a potential date. Let me introduce you to my good buddy Pradz instead. He is nice guy. He isn’t “mostly” nice. He is through & through, 100% , nice. A closeted poet, responsible social drinker, creative photographer & with an IQ of 120 to boot. I think he is THE MAN amongst all the single desi men !! Good Luck & God Bless.
IW, i was wondering too why
IW, i was wondering too why does atra always take up your case when the few single women turn up on DSS? I mean is that like a ghaati pact you guys have or what? Cut some slack for the guys down under too man. Forget me, there’s Ananth, Kculon, Nemo, and so on…
Atleast IW, you did this much, for which i’ll be (no wait), the entire south indian fraternity of single men will be ever so grateful.
IW, atra
grow up guys. don’t be juvenile!

cheers,
asuph
for HC
HC,
Interesting blog and lively comments!
My first thoughts when I read your blog (I mean- just as I read the title…)- were….Hmm, so is HC saying..there are “Boys and Men”?!
Since..imo- Men are Boys…or inside- every man there is always a boy- who is just waiting to come out in different ways..and it is not a matter of why..but when and how! (*And to my knowledge- there are no exceptions).
“I left feeling that the state of jejune juvenilia is permanent with the desi-male.”
Well, as I see it, there are no exceptions- it is universal.
But, I would not call it “juvenile”- it is simply part of the “innate nature of mankind”…and I find it amusing and sometimes to be a good thing…I can’t imagine living/being with men- who are “all mature and all grown-up, all of the time!”…kind of know that they ALL have their “boyish” moments- whether it is a Neuro-Surgeon, Rocket Scientist, Phiosopher- extraordinare, Super Priest..whatever!
And Men need their ‘affirmations/validation’ too! And perhaps that affirmation feels much better when comes from other men..and perhaps when there are Men get-togethers…they look for that..from
“one upmanship” to other traits..but it is all good:) They certainly need places in the real and virtual world..where they can be “free with no inhibitions”…it is psychologically good for them- to vent out!And once I spot a space…where this goes on…I gently shut the door and go out to do my “real feminist stuff”..and am not even curious to see- what goes on(since I already know!)
And that brings me to “Women and Girls”..and imo again…Women are Girls..and inside every woman there is a girl who wants to come out, now and then! (ok- we innately perhaps- are not so inclined/don’t have the need to express that part of us…that often as men do, nevertheless, the girl in us, is also quite alive!)
And I find Erika Jong’s writings interesting (but only- occasionally!)
Maria
atra
To remain PC, I would have stay on course bashing desi-males en-masse
It is currently vogue and endorsed by Ms Rai no less. I talked about my immediate reaction (upon seeing the e-mail thread) and my delayed response (reading the comments to my post). To me that is the whole point of seeking comment on a post - gives one a chance to re-evaluate their starting position.
Interesting feedback...
That’s a whole lot of feedback on a woman’s understanding of male-bonding elite-engineering school style. Male bashing is fashionable no question about and has precious little to do with feminism - at least the brand of feminism that appeals to me. I grew up on a diet of Erica Jong - and she totally loves men :)IMHO feminism is about celebrating the feminine and much of that celebration becomes possible with a man.
There are plenty of funny, intelligent, good-looking (and combinations thereof) desi men out there. Typically they are not exceptional academically (like most members of this mailing list I stumbled on to) but have the smarts to live a good, useful and wholesome life - maybe the reason they stay married as well
The demographic that I have dated since becoming single again are more like the folks on the mailing list - for better or worse that’s how its been
and to that extent I was able to sense the vibe of this community quickly.
Without wishing to generalize, being obsessive compulsive about any phase of one’s life renders the enjoyment of other phases of it difficult. I guess there is a time (if not at 40 then when ?) to move on, to let go and allow new things and thoughts take over.
So the next time one of these dudes met a woman for the first time he would talk about things more fun than his stellar GPA and how his intelligence opened doors to all kinds of amazing career opportunities. Worse say to her “My IQ is 160, what is yours ?” That is, I think rather juvenile.
Now hold on ...
WHat is that about ??? Lol !! its almost as if HC (a) wrote the blog and HC (b) wrote this comment !
“Without wishing to generalize, being obsessive compulsive about any phase of one’s life renders the enjoyment of other phases of it difficult. I guess there is a time (if not at 40 then when ?) to move on, to let go and allow new things and thoughts take over. “
Agree.
Chet
HC(a) feels sorry for overgrown boys who pretend to be men and are not. Sometimes sorry turns to disgust. She remembers the number of times she’s come across boy-men and how they bore her to tears. For a bit she forgets that she’s know a few real men too. She vents a little.
HC(b) remembers the kind that made her laugh and think. She puts away the broad brush that she uses to tar all “man-kind” with. There are smart, confident men who can say of themselves “There is not much to look at. I am dark, balding,and over-weight. So that fits me nicely in the 95% confidence level with guys in my sample set.”
Makes sense ?
160 holy crap! you’ve
160 holy crap! you’ve dated dudes with a 160 IQ? Thats like….umm like 40 more than me. 160!!!
I’m sure the guys are biting themselves all over for the reply you’ve given. I mean cmon im biting myself here. I thought you were a real man hating, typecast-stereotyping men, woman’s era kinda woman. I had to stereotype a woman who slotted men in one category. That’s why i said what i had to say ! Instead of coming back with an agressive pro-feminist reply, you turn back and almost blow flying kisses at us with winkies and smilies? How fair is that, i ask you?
Anyways, so are you currently looking Crossings?
Pradz
Chances are that I may get lynched by the real feminists
I am not one of them and never was. Their philosophy does not appeal to me - reading Jong at 14 took care of that. To reiterate, there are juvenile desi men out there and a lot of them. It would great if they took a chance on growing up. I could have had a fun and non-threatening conversation with the 160 IQ dude 
Asuph..
I am trying to picture myself leading a desi-female lych-mob
Maybe in another life. It sounds is a goal worth post-poning moksha for
i disagree
with all of you, on some major and some minor points.

my lawyer is currently drafting out the replies, but he’s on a drinking break
Amusing
Amusing blog and the comments here !!! Very amusing !! As some one who indulges in atleast one chain mail with atleast one group of friends : from school, UG, PG every month and as some one who makes it a point to dig up these relics which ever place I go to and indulge in backslapping .. a interpretation from a unaccounted for’s POV is very amusing !!!
HC .. dont be too quick to make such sweeping statements : “I had to wonder if their lives were so empty that they needed a relic from the past to imbue it with a sense of purpose and fullness” “I left feeling that the state of jejune juvenilia is permanent with the desi-male” Keep wondering and feeling and pondering than deciding on these !
I wonder what fills life ! I wonder what gives purpose and fullness to life !
Relics from the past !!!!
I got to look myself in the mirror when I indulge in these mail exchanges next time !
asuph
You must note that when I use the word “emancipated” I refer to the wannabe emancipated women, who go out of their way to prove their attitudes - I don’t know to who. That is the reason I have used quotes around the word emancipated.
And I do know plenty of genuinely cool women who would never indulge in desi-male bashing.
Your perception that I have characterized all emancipated women as Desi Male Bashers (damn, we need an acronym - DMB girls - howzzat?
) is quite unfounded, if you would care to go through my comments more carefully.
It is obvious that nobody who is truly emancipated (guys or girls) would indulge in bashing any gender.
Having said that, I do stand by my stand that poking fun at the desi male has become somewhat of a trend among women, and that to run down males is even becoming politically correct. To call desi males juvenile and MCPs is considered quite acceptable and is done without a second thought, and even guys have gotten so used to it that they don’t even notice that someone is calling them a pig.
As proof, I offer the easy manner in which this post is written - the author does not even pause to think that it may be in bad taste, to to reconsider if there may be another perspective which is not derogatory to the objets of her derision.
Like I pointed out, this is probably because all major feminist literature stresses an anti-male stand, and perhaps this has somehow percolated into the feminine psyche, the world over.
Apropos your words - “as far as I know they’re a minority, however vocal” - all trends are formed by minorities. I have seen this trait specifically exhibited by certain members of the society who I can only call “emancipated” (note the quotes), and rarely by those girls who actually have some brains up there.
Besides, do you or I have any proof that the silent majority does NOT sympathize with the vocal DMB minority? Certainly not, if we go by the adage - “Maun sammati-darshak”.
So far, I do not see any girl even objecting to the contents of this post. (Billo has only stepped in to comment that she is not one of the DMB girls, and to tell the males not to think of all girls as DMB girls).
For some reason people think its okay not to object to such DMB sentiments. Is this not the proof of an non-objectionable meme?
However, I can guarantee you this - if someone had written a post reviling women, there would be so many condemnations of it (by guys as well as girls), that it wouldn’t be funny anymore.
See if you can derive a conclusion from this fact.
HC, You couldn’t have
HC,
You couldn’t have chosen a better timing for this post while im chewing on content for the continuation of my next blog. I couldn’t help smiling that you had infiltrated (unknowingly of course) into an all guy group and were secretly serving yourself ladles of guy talk.
“wonder if their lives were so empty that they needed a relic from the past to imbue it with a sense of purpose and fullness”….
relic is a good word and i must say yes to what you were meaning here. For these are fellows we spent the dying teen years with, laughed, learnt and did the stupidest of things, sang loudly, crushed for the same girls, teased professors, bunked classes, chalkfights and then at the end went seperate ways. While we didn’t think much of it then, when you meet the same fellow years later, you are… no wait, guys are bound to use familiar lingo, and as conversation starters engage in verbal duals to warm up. I mean, seriously if you were looking for sophisticated and an eclectic discourse, make no mistake, you’ll get that too. Just announce yourself to the group!
Moreover, haven’t you heard the adage ‘boys will be boys’?
on a lighter note
pradz as i was reading your comment, this thought popped in: could it be that it was E’s intention all the way? get heart into the egroup, make everyone else dark and out comes the shining knight. how could she get in otherwise?
DM bashing - Ms. Rai Eishtyle
Amidst all this halla-gulla, I would like to cite how the disease of DM bashing has percolated even to Bollywood. Ms. Rai who had been so chui mui about kissing & nudity in bollywood movies (with desi male bollywood heroes in it), had a major change of heart once she went saat samundar paar in Hollywood. Now she seen parroting the much cliched line - “If done aesthetically, & if the story demands, why not?? ” Read it all Here . Now isn’t this another variation of DM bashing ?? Indian heroes too lowly to kiss.. Hollywood heroes - naah , they are so cool !!
Sorry for the interruption..bhaai n behen logs.. Lagey raho.
Juzzz kidding
a kiss is not just a kiss
“a kiss is not just a kiss in Bollywood movies”
So sayeth Ms. Rai.
C’mon IW, doesn’t it show that she thinks desi guys are extra special! Far from male-bashing, Ms. Rai is preserving her “you’re worth it” Loreal lips for that special desi-guy who will bhangra into her life!

billo
Certainly.
You might still agree with me that there are many more “emancipated” women indulging in desi-male-bashing than those who adopt a more balanced outlook.
And this is not a gender war - it is simply a worrying social trend that I pointed out. One cannot call the identification of a social trend as a gender war or be in denial on the existence of this social trend among the wannabe liberated women.
And such a trend unfortunately has far-reaching consequences for society. I believe the roots of this lie again in the women’s lib movement that began in the western countries, where male bashing was seen as the sign of liberation. Even this is undeniable, if one looks at feminist literature. One walks away feeling that it is impossible to be a feminist without running down guys.
Men and women need to be more understanding of each other - we live in an era where rapidly shifting socio-cultural paradigms are putting both the genders in difficult positions all the time. Women have their sets of problems, and so do men.
The relationship must be affectionate and happy - not one in which one repeatedly identifies negative qualities of the opposite gender.
There has to be a collaborative approach to meeting the problems of contemporary society.
atra...
I posted a reply to your comment with a live example from my professional life. But dunno why it says : The comment you posted has been flagged as potential spam. It will not be visible until the site administrator has a chance to review it.
I hope the comment becomes visible soon.
CN
I agree fully.
However, my concern is not so much for the boys as much as it is for the girls who seem to be suffering from this specific malady of seeing only negative things in desi males.
The extent of this disease of negative perception will be brought out if you try to seriously answer the question I asked earlier - when was the last time you heard a girl speak positively of desi guys as a group?
However, you will note that they speak disparagingly of desi guys all the time.
This negative perception does not bode well for the girls (and neither for society, if you consider how women actually indoctrinate the next generation) - desi society is headed towards dysfunctional families, if girls internalize this negative perception of desi guys.
Consider this specific post, for example.
The guys are merely bonding with each other (which is seriously nothing even remotely negative).
Yet, even this simple and harmless act of friendship/networking is seen in a negative light by desi girls.
What does this tell one?
Is this attitude not the definite precursor of dysfunctional relationships between guys and girls?
How exactly is a girl going to be able to relate with guys in a healthy manner, if she sees negative things in something as harmless as this?
Magic circle...
HC,
I agree with atra and asupha… I’m myself a part of such a thing which we boys [we still haven’t grown up according to you] call a magic circle. Though there is a subtle difference between our ‘network’ and the network that you’ve written about, it is essentially something that we keep alive to achieve some objectives. At the superficial level, it may look juvenile, but the way the magic circle comes alive when one of our guy is in trouble is truly magical… A guy wants a job change desperately? He got it. A guy wants a surety for a home loan? He got it… No matter what strings have to be pulled, it’ll be done. But it is not publicised, not because the boys are not garrulous, but because they know someday they may be at the recieving end. Much of the serious talk happen over phone or the tête-à-tête over coffees or beer.
But why am I explaining all this? Who cares what the girls think of us? Let us boys be boys…
heartcrossing
i belong to the age group you mentioned but not to any high end institutions. college is the first place from home where usually ‘sky is limit’ and there are many idiotic things one does with friends. the camaraderie that one experiences at this age is hardly found in the current work places. the warm fuzz one gets while in aim less, politically and socially incorrect talks with college friends is difficult to explain. there is no need to pretend to be someone else. but just because one talks bullshit in these avenues does not mean the person is incapable of sensible talk.
The emancipated woman
Asuph,
Yeah, I agree - this seems to be a distinct characteristic of the “emancipated” woman - to criticize the desi male.
Its become the defacto standard to measure the coolness quotient of girls (“You don’t jeer and mock desi males? Then you are just not emancipated enough, dahling. Do you actually like anything about desi guys? You must be such a backward woman, then”)
And of course, when it becomes a subliminal rule to knock someone, then one can find fault with even the way they breath.
Its easy to see that this is the new hallmark herd-mentality of the wannabe modern desi female - to knock desi guys.
When was the last time you heard an Indian girl say something remotely appreciative about desi guys?
atra i don't agree
that this is a distinct characteristic of the cmancipated woman – criticizng the desi male. again that sort of generalization is what i’m questioning. on both fronts. i don’t know how understanding is going to foster if we insist on such blanket generalizations.
i know a lot of desi women who do not ridicule/criticise desi male as a group. sure they make fun of certain specimans, but that’s legit as far as i’m concerned.
i don’t know if desi male bashing has become a barometer of coolness in girls. i frankly don’t know that many desi girls. my observations are are limited to a few bloggers, and writers, and as far as i know they’re a minority, however vocal.
regards,
asuph
hmmm
Well, its perhaps too early for me to say, considering that I have lived less than 3 decades… but from my observation of my peer group, I think men do a reality check every time they hit a decade (the first decade does not count, since they arent men yet then). When they near a twenty, there’s this sudden frenzy to round up and get back in touch with high school peers and find out who got into a better college or a worse one.. whoz bike is faster.. who’s got a girlfriend and who doesnt.. and if you did have one, whos gf is hotter…
The next enthusiastic frenzy to bond with old buddies, both from school and college happens when they are near about hitting the dreaded 30s.. this time its to assess whether the rest are as bald as them and developing a paunch.. if they are the only ones unmarried or there are more of them (they seek solace in numbers).. if they have a wife, they’ll flaunt them out by dressing them up in yards of saree.. if its a gf they’ll flaunt them by dressing them down in the shortest of skirts..then ofcourse comes the cars, the house.. etc etc..
Unfair
HC,
I believe your observation of the facts is accurate, and your interpretation is uncharitable. I believe the unfair interpretation arises from not having an inside view of the “old-boy’s network”, and thats completely understandable. These virtual old-boy’s groups are a new phenomenon, of our age (entirely different from the clubs that people used to hang out at, in the pre-BBS and pre-internet eras) - hence the way they operate is not fully understood.
There are some old-world paradigms, and some entirely new ones, too.
Old College and school friends hang out with each other because they like to hang out with each other. If they do not have anything of substance to talk about, even then they still give each other a holler.
Its called keeping in touch.
(Personally, I find it charming when someone gives me a holler without any agenda whatsoever. I think the modern world is too conditioned by its ideas of what is of consequence, and what is mature and what becomes who. I find the buckwass that happens at DSS charming, too - even though it touches the extremes of inanities sometimes. In that playfulness, there is profundity, IMO)
Now, why one should keep in touch (or does keep in touch) with old friends - that is something that is a different subject, and I think I do not want to gloss over it here.
About people not talking anything mature and of substance -
I am sure you recall that even in college and schools there were larger groups and there were subgroups. Anything of substance is normally not discussed in public zones - it is typically only broached there and then the conversation is carried to private emails.
Today, I accidentally find myself a member of at least 4 virtual alumni groups, and on the surface, the groups function exactly as you observe - non-substantial talk.
However, I have been amazed to find the undercurrents (the private conversations within the groups) to be enormously significant. There are some very serious conversations, discussions, plans of actions on various subjects.
And the deepest layer of these undercurrents is of those who actually act, not just talk.
Accordingly, in all of these subgroups, there are people who are getting together for various purposes - some to form common interest groups. We have a bird-watching group (now, I am quite sure there are some who do not find birdwatching as something responsible or mature enough to suit a man who has bills to pay, but what the hell!), a civic responsibilities group, a group that goes and helps street kids - and probably other groups that I don’t even know about, because I did not interact on some subject that led to the formation of that private sub-group.
Some alumni friends I interacted with - I was amazed to see the kind of things they were doing by networking.
Its in various layers. Some surface layers are inane, and the deeper layers are substantial.
To see only one side would be to miss the larger and more complete picture.
bang on target, atra
agree with most of you said here, atra. couldn’t have expressed it better.
another thing that I find unfair is lumping of the “desi male” into a monolithic stereotype. HC is not the first one to do this, of course, and that makes it even more boring. Some of the new ‘emancipated’ women have suddenly made it a point to caricaturize the desi male/indian male/… by sharing their weird dates, conversations on messengers/phone and so on. it’s kinda got pretty monotonous and dead boring. so yes there are idiotic guys so are there idotic girls, desi or otherwise. shall we move on?
clear perspectives! sigh. if i said anything more, it would probably look like a personal criticism, so i’ll refrain. just a hint there, HC. again, read atra’s last line carefully – maybe that had something to do with the said disasters?
regards,
asuph.
hmmmm
Some of the new ‘emancipated’ women have suddenly made it a point to caricaturize the desi male/indian male/… by sharing their weird dates, conversations on messengers/phone and so on.
guilty as charged.
But then again, aren’t all the comments/commentators here just guilty of the charge they are making, one of broad( pun not intentended) generalisation.
Not all desi women caricaturize the entire desi male population, Just the particular examples. I know I’ve had my fair share of those , but then again, most of my friends are desi guys. Thats saying something right there.
So do we really need to get into gender wars here and get our collective proverbials in a knot ?
ah bilbo
I started with “some of the”, not all. Of course not all desi women caricaturize desi males.
I wasn’t alluding even partly to you, although I now realize you had written one blog with chat transcripts or something. I don’t remember what was that. I’ve nothing against using real life convos/incidents. You want to say, hey I meet weirdos all the time, go right ahead. It’s when people start generalizing and putting down a very diverse group of people based on some random examples that it gets my goat.
Specifically something like:
I left feeling that the state of jejune juvenilia is permanent with the desi-male. They never quite break free from the familiar cocoon of the college fraternity. Their identity at middle age is still defined by nicknames bestowed upon them as 18 year olds by other 18 year olds and 20 year old jokes regurgitated ad nauseum.
Tell me if that is not insulting? And tell me where in my comment have I generalized? And tell me why do you want to soften up the highly objectionable caricatures by claiming that *all the commentors* here are guilty of the same charge? Tell me even where does atra’s first comment make sweeping generalizations?
A man making such blanket statements about women would have been lynched at by now, verbally, called names like MCP and what not. And if HC had the time, she’d be the leader of the lynching mob. So don’t give me we all are screwed up. We might be, but right now there is a specific screw up that we’re talking about. Let’s not dilute the debate.
cheers,
asuph.